When as an undergraduate in 1951 I told a senior student of history that a career in his field seemed an attractive choice, and asked his advice about how to pursue such a goal. In reply he suggested that I pick a country like, say, Bulgaria, and set about to learn everything I could about it, its history, geography, language, politics, religion, cuisine, etc. and become an academic authority on everything bulgur.
Bulgaria? Basque? Bolivia? Burundi? No thanks, even at age 18 I knew that it was human history, or language, or religion, politics or cuisine that attracted me. Like the fox of Isaiah Berlin, I hungered to understand many things, not to become just a hedgehog with expertise in One Big Thing, like Patagonian railways, Chinese poetry, Finnish grammar, faint blue stars, or the origin of sexual desire, etc. My Bible was De Rerum Natura (The Nature of Things) by Lucretius.
Thirst for a broad understanding led over time to the study in science of humans as physical entities, their beliefs, behaviours, and their perceived worlds of atoms, stars, and ideas. Being a human myself, this included self knowledge where possible and accepting constraints when not.
Two books recently reviewed are relevant to these thoughts about history:
Endless Flight by Keiron Pin is a biography of Eastern European journalist and author Joseph Roth (1894-1939), born in Brody, Ukraine, known at that time as the region of Galicia in the Austro-Hungarian Empire. After the first world war it became part of Poland, was occupied by Germany during WW2, then the USSR, and eventually Ukraine with the collapse of the USSR. (Now of course it is subject to invasion again, this time by post-Soviet Russia.)
Roth was peripatetic and alcoholic, ever relocating from hotel to hotel throughout European cities, and preferentially writing in the mileux of bars. He is best known for his novel of the last days of the Habsburg Empire The Radetzky March, conjuring a musty time lost and never regained, like the Magic Mountain of Thomas Mann, and unlike the France of Marcel Proust.
Sarah Bakewell’s Humanly Possible is a nonfictional account of the idea of humanism over the past 700 years in Europe, a celebration of the positive features of a civilization gradually discarding supernatural ideation of itself, and constrained by adherence to religious belief.
Bakewell presents short positive accounts of writers over this period, from Petrarch and Boccaccio to John Stuart Mill and Bertrand Russell, and the picture displayed is one of gradual appearance of enlightened human ideas, of progressing toward individual liberty, and freedom of ideas.
The endless flight of Joseph Roth encapsulated a view of history that seems more realistic than the cheerful accounts of Bakewell, not to mention the sober characterization by Marx of the past “laying like a nightmare upon the present”. The violence and hatreds of wars over imaginary lines on the ground continue as always, while the catastrophic human caused climate change steadily renders humanity more like a disease upon the natural world than a glorification of what is humanly possible.
August 24, 2023.