Explaining Quantum Theory

After his recent blog exhibiting how artificial intelligence can be used to explain Einstein’s Theory of Relativity, I challenged English blogger John Fleming to explore how AI can deal with other more difficult concepts such as quantum theory. This is following in the footsteps of British physicist Jim Al-Khalili, who as a human being, addressed this same issue in the Ladybird Expert Book Quantum Mechanics (2017). Fleming’s results are impressive and may be read at

Quantum Theory as explained by two Artificial Intelligences and an 8-year-old

Plenty of food for thought arises from this issue. One advantage ot the Ladybird book are the many colourful full-page illustrations provided to entertain the reluctant reader, soothing the swallowing of unfamiliar ideas contrary to common sense. Fleming’s blog goes straight to the point, a no-nonsense approach from different sources, all non-human.

These results from artificial intelligence clearly display work already done by humans, initial reasoning by physicists who founded the theories of quantum mechanics like Planck, Heisenberg and others.

How this unfolds in the days ahead remains to be seen, bearing in mind that every new scientific development inevitably has found some application to use in the development of new weaponry.

This is what worries me more than the beneficial and educational potential of using AI to expand the range of human understanding of the nature of things.
September 8, 2023

New Thermal Equilibrium

Awakened at 0500 to a loud throaty purr, I arose with thoughts of the planet’s atmosphere now moving to a new thermal equilibrium. This change is caused by human burning of hydrocarbons, and presumably will progress until a new balance is attained, by decreasing carbon release and/or increasing its capture.

The transition will be painful for humanity, provoking wars (possibly nuclear) and civil unrest. Survivors, if any, will require great resilience, and a broad population decrease is bound to occur from the present >8 billion.

The foreseeable future is parlous for homo sapiens as a natural species. Any effect of artificial intelligence on this outcome remains to be seen.

 I arose, fed the cat, brewed a pot of coffee, and ate a couple of Timbits.

David Attenborough maintains there are ways of dealing with this and we can reverse it again. I can’t agree with this assumption— it is only a conditional statement. He suggests that since we humans are the only living creatures who can look into the future, we will find ways to avert our own extinction.

I would like to share his hopeful opinion, but I don’t, for consumerism is unlikely to reverse worldwide. One point of no return was in 2014 for just ocean warming— reversal would take centuries and significant decrease in the inborn human competitiveness of degrading the atmosphere, accomplishing “degrowth”

Some humans may better adjust to higher temperatures than others and over eons of time, natural selection could again lead to civilized and sustainable human life, but don’t count on it. Hope for a return to status quo ante is unrealistic.

Time now to pat the cat, brew and consume another pot of coffee, and scarf 2 more Timbits.

September 3, 2023

Reviewing Reviews and Reviewers

Subscribing to a number of literary periodicals allows a reader to develop over time a sense of quality recognition, not only of the texts of individual authors, but also of the book reviewers themselves. Presumably, the object of reading the review of a book is that of informing oneself about its contents and quality of writing, before undertaking its purchase. Authors and publishers alike seek positive reviews to promote their works, and fear negative ones that may inhibit sales.

Good fiction reviews may spark life-changing consequences. When an obscure emigré Russian college professor hit the jackpot with a controversial bestseller and subsequent film, this allowed Vladimir Nabokov to quit teaching and retire to a luxury Swiss hotel with his spouse for the rest of his life, after his bestseller novel Lolita appeared in 1955.

Nonfiction may be chancy except for books written by or about celebrities, and books about ideas that become fashionable. Irish philosopher Alex Moran, writing in the Times Literary Supplement of August 11, 2023, discussed Living for Pleasure: An Epicurean Guide to Life by Emily A. Austin. The reviewer summarized the contents, first clarifying what epicurism is not, then briefly describing three primary kinds of desire: the necessary, like food, water, friendship, and understanding nature; the pleasurable but not necessary, like fine wines and cuisine; and finally, those best avoided, like power and great wealth, that often lead to tragedy and loss.

A satisfactory review hopefully entices a potential reader to buy a copy, but may also function as a learning experience for an interested consumer of information about ideas, who may not want to read all 256 pages of a text involving the details of epicurean philosophy.

This may be a fine line in some cases, as was mocked in the Monty Python sketch “Summarize Proust”.

Unfavourable and hypercritical reviews tend to reveal much about the reviewer. A sensible and neutral review may comment on how a book may have missed certain aspects of the subject, but worded inoffensively. Trashing a text is bound to offend the author, often leading to entertaining debate in the letters-to-the-editor pages of a journal. Nitpicking commentary about usage, grammar, or punctuation on the other hand merely suggests excessive rigidity of the reviewer.

“Fair but Critical” is a good motto for a reviewer in the opinion of this writer, who as an author has written both books and reviews. So far I haven’t been attacked by any other authors.

August 28, 2023

No Escape From the Past

When as an undergraduate in 1951 I told a senior student of history that a career in his field seemed an attractive choice, and asked his advice about how to pursue such a goal. In reply he suggested that I pick a country like, say, Bulgaria, and set about to learn everything I could about it, its history, geography, language, politics, religion, cuisine, etc. and become an academic authority on everything bulgur.

Bulgaria? Basque? Bolivia? Burundi?  No thanks, even at age 18 I knew that it was human history, or language, or religion, politics or cuisine that attracted me. Like the fox of Isaiah Berlin, I hungered to understand many things, not to become just a hedgehog with expertise in One Big Thing, like Patagonian railways, Chinese poetry, Finnish grammar, faint blue stars, or the origin of sexual desire, etc. My Bible was  De Rerum Natura (The Nature of Things) by Lucretius.

Thirst for a broad understanding led over time to the study in science of humans as physical entities, their beliefs, behaviours, and their perceived worlds of atoms, stars, and ideas. Being a human myself, this included self knowledge where possible and accepting constraints when not.

Two books recently reviewed are relevant to these thoughts  about history:

Endless Flight by Keiron Pin is a biography of Eastern European journalist and author Joseph Roth (1894-1939), born in Brody, Ukraine, known at that time as the region of Galicia in the Austro-Hungarian Empire. After the first world war it became part of Poland, was occupied by Germany during WW2, then the USSR, and eventually Ukraine with the collapse of the USSR. (Now of course it is subject to invasion again, this time by post-Soviet Russia.)

Roth was peripatetic and alcoholic, ever relocating from hotel to hotel throughout European cities, and preferentially writing in the mileux of bars. He is best known for his novel of the last days of the Habsburg Empire The Radetzky March, conjuring a musty time lost and never regained, like the Magic Mountain of Thomas Mann, and unlike the France of Marcel Proust.

Sarah Bakewell’s Humanly Possible is a nonfictional account of the idea of humanism over the past 700 years in Europe, a celebration of the positive features of a civilization gradually discarding supernatural ideation of itself, and constrained by adherence to religious belief.

Bakewell presents short positive accounts of writers over this period, from Petrarch and Boccaccio to John Stuart Mill and Bertrand Russell, and the picture displayed is one of gradual appearance of enlightened human ideas, of progressing toward individual liberty, and freedom of ideas.

The endless flight of Joseph Roth encapsulated a view of history that seems more realistic than the cheerful accounts of Bakewell, not to mention the sober characterization by Marx of the past “laying like a nightmare upon the present”. The violence and hatreds of wars over imaginary lines on the ground continue as always, while the catastrophic human caused climate change steadily renders humanity more like a disease upon the natural world than a glorification of what is humanly possible.

August 24, 2023.

Immortal, Invisible

On opening the new Literary Review this morning and ignoring two pieces devoted to the dismal science of economics “Follow the Money”, I alit on a more congenial section designated “Art of Writing” that opened with a discussion of the genre of biography, provoked by a recent book, Lifescapes: A Biographer’s Search for the Soul, by Ann Wroe.

The reviewer, British writer and historian Gillian Tindall, identifies the author as “…the product of a Roman Catholic childhood, alive to the weight of symbolism and perception of the soul as ‘another organ’, like the heart and lungs. In non-religious terms, her search is for the unique essence of individuals.”

Stop right there. The title Immortal, Invisible, suggests that a biographer has a unique  talent for describing an abstract characterization of an author’s approach to life, but the phrase “unique essence” is no more informative than the word “soul” as a concrete human quality. Fair enough, sounds good, but what exactly are we talking about?

There seems to be a whiff of indeterminacy here, akin to that of physical science, both classical electromagnetic field theory and quantum mechanics, wherein we also use words and symbols to understand and share abstractions to describe the world and people we live with.

The monthly Literary Review is replete with a rich stew of ideas providing material for digestion throughout the day that may emerge as blog/essays of my own that I post to my site and sometimes to Facebook, unless provoked to authorial constipation by episodes of ennui.

After this unproductive regression of thinking about thinking, I resumed reading the essay by Tindall, whose writing about biographers resonates with my own experience in reading works in this genre, though often fiction may better convey a sense of an author’s “soul”, when forming an image of a character. Raskolnikov in Dostoevsky’s early work Crime and Punishment may echo the author’s fears about humanity when young, while the three brothers Karamazov in his final novel expand this fear into a tripartite portrait of “unique human  essence”.

This verbiage arose from having read one page of a literary magazine at breakfast. After all, a soul is only an idea, supposedly immortal and invisible, and thereby a figment of the imagination, like a quark.

August 14, 2023.

Influencers

The sobriquet of “influencer” is employed to describe individuals who attain notoriety on social media, a usage that I initially found annoying, me being a relic of the last century and unaccustomed to those abrupt changes in language appearing, as usual, among the young. Rather than complaining about neologisms however, it seems reasonable to use them in the title of this brief essay about two historical figures who clearly merited that adjective, owing to their influence on the thinking of those who followed, but perceived as negative by ecclesiastic authorities and controlling rulers.

Erasmus of Rotterdam (1466-1536) was a kindly and humane man who was a priest and scholar in many intellectual centres of Western Europe and even in the little offshore island of Britain. He saw his mission as one of reforming the Catholic doctrines from within the established Church, in contrast to the demands of his upstart colleague Martin Luther (1483-1546), who published his “95 Theses” in 1517, igniting the Protestant Reformation and a century of mutual hatreds and religious wars.

Michel de Montaigne (1533-1592) was not a cleric but a landowner and local politician in southwestern France, remembered today for his many essays commenting on the human condition and sound advice on how to live a good life, despite the mayhem of religious conflict in his land.

English writer Sarah Bakewell’s recent book Humanly Possible about the development of humanistic thought over the past 700 years groups these two contrasting authors together to display their moderate and non- dogmatic approach to major issues of their time, in a chapter setting the stage for the later development of the Enlightenment. Wide dissemination of their ideas only became possible with the development of a new technology, the use of moveable type in the mid-XV century to make printed copies of their writings accessible to any literate reader, at first in Latin, and later in living regional languages.

Both Erasmus and Montaigne were major “influencers” in preparing the ground tor the Enlightenment, advancing the cause of humanity in the face of traditional rigid thinking in religious scripture and regional powers.

This turning point in the history of ideas provoked by printing suggests a unique transitional  epoch that is echoed by later revolutions like telegraphy and telephonic communication in the XIX century, followed by radio, television, and eventual digital revolutions in the late XX and early XXI centuries. Anyone with access to mass communication is now a potential “influencer”, and as was the case with the invention of printing, using these new techniques for manipulating others does not necessarily result in a benefit to humanity.

Joseph Goebbels was a master “influencer” as was also Martin Luther King.

Being an “influencer” by itself doesn’t guarantee an ethical outcome, but that’s another story.

Fidelis cave

August 10, 2023

Conditional Reassurance

Conditional reassurance about the climate crisis unfolding around us as foreseen decades ago by scientists, usually involves soothing statements along the lines of “we can succeed if we only….”

Using the first person plural “we” implies the possibility of united action in a metaphorical “war” against a natural phenomenon, but a longer view of history and of the human ability to cooperate for the common good leads to a bleaker conclusion, exploited by media and the entertainment industry in monetizing understandable human fears of social collapse.

Retired as both a professional astronomer and psychiatrist, I have my doubts about the likelihood of a happy ending to the observed and documented current climate change in the planetary environment.

“If we could “fix” climate change, we would still have the problems of overpopulation, consumerism, and finite resources; of democratic capitalism.

We can’t vote our way out of this, not from the city, suburbs or countryside; not when the rule makers live in mansions, on palatial estates, and on their own private cruise ships. Unfortunately the system of democratic capitalism requires everyone to toe the line of consumerism just to survive. Without doing so society would collapse. But what would be worse, a planned, organized collapse / restructuring, or a collapse due to lack of food and resources.”

The above observation by a commentator recently appeared in The Conversation in a discussion about conditional reassurance, calling so-called “fear mongering” complaints by a respected scientist as a form of denial. This is a welcome response to reassurance and soothing responses to the crisis by politicians encouraging us to all “work together” to ameliorate if not solve the problem.

Historian Peter Turchin in his new book End Times is not referring to the climate concern but to unstable social cohesion, suggesting two main factors predicting collapse: increasing disparity between the extremely rich and the immiserated poor, along with  overproduction of elites leading to a glut of unemployed intellectuals. The first was characteristic of events in the late Roman republic of the first century BCE, and both in prerevolutionary Russia in the early XX century, the Weimar Republic in 1930s Germany, and  are present this time in the USA , the UK, and other regimes claiming to be democratic.

In the The London Review of Books this summer we read  “…the explosion in the number of billionaires [in Britain] over the past few decades and accelerating inequality and growing poverty are, in fact, two sides of the same coin.”

These conditions historically appear to be associated with impending social collapse and regime change, described by the Greek historian Polybius in the middle Hellenistic period 220-146 BCE in his anacyclic view of history.

There is nothing new under the sun.

August 5, 2023

Ghosts

“A ghost is the soul or spirit of a dead person or non-human animal that is believed to be able to appear to the living.”

This brief definition of the noun  from Wikipedia unveils a long discussion of its origin that is informative reading for one interested in related arcane beliefs popular throughout human history. Scholarly studies of this form of supernatural ideation abound in anthropology, literature, history, psychiatry, and religious studies. One of every five Americans are said to maintain such beliefs even in the XXI century, illustrating the propensity of pseudoscience to taint the general knowledge base in that unhappy land and beyond.

The ability of social media to promote irrationality in the general population is undeniable, and serves to promote a psychological grasping at straws among a populace drowning in a sea of physical and mental distress, provoked by the human desire to maintain hope in face of their destruction of the environment, now unfolding as forecast by scientists decades ago.

In literature, when used as a verb, we have ghostwriting, a form of pseudo memoir written anonymously and marketed as though it were the product of the narrators themselves. The recent bestseller Spare, an alleged memoir of a member of the British monarchy, is a prime example of this genre, an “as told to” account, marketed as relating the thoughts and feelings of the second son of King Charles III.

The “spare” member of the Windsor family, in case of death or unavailability of his elder brother destined to be the future Prince of Wales after his father ascended to the throne, Spare is openly promoted as a memoir by Prince Harry, Duke of Sussex, released on 10 January 2023.

Admittedly, it was ghostwritten by J. R. Moehringer and published by Penguin.

An extended apologia pro opere sua by the ghostwriter appeared in The New Yorker magazine subsequently, and he carefully described his sincere attempt to capture the essence of the spare prince’s emotions, caused by his unwanted situation within the royal family, initially maturing as the second choice in succession to the throne, and then this uncomfortable position slowly being further degraded by the births of children of his older brother Prince William. Such are the vicissitudes of primogeniture.

The process of undertaking a commission to ghostwrite a memoir resembles the professional work of a psychiatrist evaluating the mental status of a patient, in that both try to imagine what it must be like to be their subject, involving personal interviews. Earlier, a priest confessor occupied that role for believers troubled by their “sins”, granting absolution for what now is only a matter of mental status reports, public opinion, and book sales.

Common to the activities of believers in the supernatural and of professional ghostwriters hired to write memoirs of another is the presence of pseudoscience in the former and constructing an image of experiencing another’s personal thoughts and behaviours in the latter. Both are basically forms of deception, the former about supposed activities of the undead, and the latter about about thoughts and actions of the those still living.

The concept of ghosts is a rich meme throughout the history of ideas, from Homer and Virgil to Freud and Ibsen, and relevant to those who think about it today.

July 30, 2023

The Fatal Flaw

Writing an opinion piece in The Guardian yesterday, a climate scientist bemoaned the fact that he and his colleagues decades ago had described the consequences of runaway atmospheric heating caused by burning hydrocarbons to provide energy for human expansion, echoing the curse of the Trojan princess Cassandra, having the gift of knowing the future but  being ignored, and seeing her city destroyed by an invading army.

The modern version of “cassandrism” is reflected in the current climate crisis, attributed to universal human greed facilitated by the economic structures of capitalism, permitting enrichment of the powerful at the expense of those less successful in attaining power. This may be seen as a fatal flaw of democratic systems, allowing all voters to elect leaders, but assuming that sweet reason operates as decision making. though competition for power and personal advancement is the underlying drive. Electors are always susceptible to the blandishments and promises of those seeking power.

But the problem lies deeper than competition between systems of economics and distribution of political power. It is an inherent feature of living organisms to struggle for survival and reproduction. Organic life in general maintains and expands, creating its niches in the universe. The profit motive of humans may be our fatal flaw, reflected in the drive to survive, to grow, and to expand our domain at any cost.

A biota may survive for a while with a balance of nature between predators and prey, but destruction of that balance provokes a tipping point and the extermination of the losers.

Unfortunately, the fatal flaw of humans is biological, not political or economic. If blame is sought for this unhappy situation, blame the invisible hands of our parents: Mother Nature and Father Time.

July 28, 2023

My recent book Eclipse (2023) is available from the author by personal barter in Canada and by mail order from elsewhere for $20.00. My earlier essay collections Stardust (2021) including memoir Foxtrot and Meteors (2022), are in print and available to purchase from Canadian bookshops and online.

Framing: Food For Thought

To frame something is to assign boundary limits, that may be temporal, involving onset and termination of an interval, or spatial, specifying location in a dimensional space: scalar as a continuous line, or multiple like a plane surface, or higher like cubic or three dimensional, and still higher abstractions appearing in pure mathematics. The process of defining physical boundaries in space and time. is thus not simple.

Culinary boundaries of dinner may be framed by appetizers and desserts framing an entrée. Pitch or playing field boundaries may be represented by chalk lines on a flat surface, indicating when a play is performed within or without of assigned limits. An opera may be bound by an overture and a finale. A spherical surface is bound by only two dimensions, a hypothetical string theory universe in physics by eleven, and a Möbius strip challenges our very concept of dimensionality (except for pure mathematicians like my brother-in-law Leon Green, who worked in the area of differential geometry and had a terrific sense of humour about his arcane discipline.)

So why am I writing about abstract ideas like framing and dimensionality immediately after breakfast? Blame it on the Literary Review, a monthly magazine from the UK consisting of scholarly discussions of new books published in the English language, both written and translated from other scripts and tongues. Other similar journals like the New York and London Reviews of Books and the Times Literary Supplement are broadsheet periodicals requiring two hands to conveniently peruse. The Literary Review however is of a standard size, commensurate to being propped up by my porridge bowl at the breakfast table, providing food for the mind along with fuel for the body, and often provoking a reaction in the form of writing a blog/essay like today’s discussion of a new book about the nature of literary criticism as an academic discipline developing in the early XX century.

Describing how I have arrived at a subject to write about may thus be thought of as a peculiar form of literary criticism that is self-referential, describing a particular source of inspiration to write about itself.

Food for thought.

July 25, 2023

My recent book Eclipse (2023) is available from the author by personal barter in Canada and by mail order from elsewhere for $20.00. My earlier essay collections Stardust (2021) including memoir Foxtrot and Meteors (2022), are in print and available to purchase from Canadian bookshops and online.